What Really Happens to Your Muscles on a GLP-1 Diet Gone Wrong
- Jennifer Hardy
- 3 days ago
- 8 min read
People love to talk about weight loss wins with GLP-1s like semaglutide or tirzepatide. The before-and-afters are dramatic. But what you don’t see in those pictures? The lean muscle quietly vanishing under the scale’s praise.
Unless you're prioritizing the right fuel—especially protein—that loss can be permanent and problematic. It might sound like a scare tactic to get you to eat healthily, but the risks are all too real.
Legg Day Fitness is committed to sharing accurate and helpful information about GLP-1 diets. We want to help people understand why semaglutide and tirzepatide are changing the food, fitness, and wellness landscape. But we also want to hone in one why certain things are specifically critical for a GLP-1 diet.
What are the real risks of losing muscle mass? How can you tell if you're eating right or wrong for your muscles? And is it too late to fix it? Let's get into it.
What Do Muscles Actually Do?
Muscles aren’t just about looking toned in photos. They’re responsible for movement, strength, stability, posture, and balance. They help regulate blood sugar, support bone density and even affect hormone levels.
Muscles Regulate Your Metabolism
Muscle is metabolically active, which means it burns calories even at rest. The more lean muscle you have, the more energy your body requires to function—even while sleeping.
Lose that muscle, and your metabolism slows down, which is one reason people gain weight back so quickly after extreme diets or unintentional under-eating (which is common on GLP-1s).
Muscles Stabilize and Protect Your Body
They keep your posture aligned, reduce joint strain, and help prevent injury. Weak glutes? Hello, lower back pain. Weak core? There goes your balance.
You don’t just feel this when exercising—you feel it getting out of bed, standing up from a chair, or carrying groceries.
Muscles Help Regulate Blood Sugar
Muscles are one of the primary storage tanks for glucose. They help clear sugar from the blood and make insulin more effective. Less muscle means poorer blood sugar control—which is especially important for those with insulin resistance, prediabetes, or Type 2 diabetes (a huge overlap with GLP-1 users).
Muscles Influence Hormones and Aging
Muscle helps regulate hormones like estrogen and testosterone, which affect fat distribution, energy, and mood. Low muscle mass is linked to higher cortisol, increased inflammation, and faster biological aging.
This becomes even more significant as estrogen drops in perimenopause and beyond, which already predisposes women to lose lean mass faster.
Muscles as an Energy Source: Your Body’s Last Resort
Your muscles are also the body’s backup energy source—if you don’t fuel properly, your body starts breaking down muscle to survive. Your body sees muscle as optional unless you give it a reason to keep it—through strength training and consistent protein intake.
Losing muscle isn't just about getting weaker. It affects how your entire body functions—metabolically, physically, and hormonally.
How Muscles Change in Women Over 30, 40, and 50
Muscle mass naturally starts to decline after age 30. By the time you’re 40, you could be losing 3–8% per decade if you’re not strength training or eating enough protein.
By 50, hormonal shifts during perimenopause and menopause, like lower estrogen levels, make it even harder to maintain lean mass. At the same time, it's much easier to gain fat in its place. Add in a calorie deficit (intentional or unintentional), and your body will gladly ditch muscle to conserve energy.
The problem? Less muscle means a slower metabolism, more fatigue, and a higher risk of injury. And this happens faster for women, especially if you're not lifting or eating enough.
How Muscles Break Down: The Mechanics of Muscle Loss
Think of your muscle as your retirement fund—the one your body quietly relies on when times get lean.
When you're eating too little, especially protein, your body doesn’t just burn fat. It starts withdrawing from your muscle account, converting it into amino acids that your liver turns into glucose to keep you alive and functioning.
Your brain and red blood cells need fuel, and if it’s not coming in through your mouth, it’s getting pulled from your muscles.
Sure, that’s efficient. But it’s expensive.
Every withdrawal drains your long-term stability:
Your metabolism slows (less muscle = fewer calories burned at rest)
You get weaker and fatigue faster
Recovery takes longer
Blood sugar control slips
And here’s the kicker: muscle is slow to rebuild, especially in your 40s and 50s. Once it’s gone, you can’t just “eat more” and bounce back overnight. You’ve got to re-invest—consistently and with intention. Without resistance training, it’s like never depositing into your savings and hoping interest alone carries you.
The Science of Why Trained and Fed Muscles Stick Around
This leads to a key question: what signals tell the body to preserve muscle versus break it down for energy?
When you strength train, your muscles experience tiny tears from the stress. That mechanical tension triggers a powerful internal signal called mTOR—a pathway that tells your body, “We need to repair and rebuild this tissue.”
But mTOR only kicks in when two things happen: you’ve challenged your muscles, and you’ve eaten enough protein (especially amino acids like leucine). This process is called muscle protein synthesis. Without that signal—or enough protein—your body shifts toward muscle protein breakdown, using muscle for energy instead.
The takeaway? Your muscles only stay if they’re used and fed. Otherwise, your body reclaims them.
Are You Losing Muscle or Just Losing Weight?
It can be hard to tell. One of the biggest misconceptions is that a smaller, thinner body equals a healthier one. But flabby arms, flat glutes, poor posture, and sagging skin can all be signs of muscle loss—not just fat loss or loose skin.
Here’s how to get clues:
Bioimpedance scales can give a rough estimate of muscle mass vs. fat, though they’re not perfect.
DEXA scans are much more accurate if accessible.
Strength changes are a big clue: if you’re getting weaker, slower, or more easily winded, that’s not just fat loss—it could be muscle loss.
Sagging skin from fast weight loss can mimic muscle loss visually. But if you feel like your limbs are deflating or you can’t hold yourself up as easily (especially core strength), that’s likely lean tissue disappearing.
And yes, this can happen even if the scale says you’re crushing it.
Get a Smart Scale to Monitor Muscles on GLP-1 Diets
As an aside, I invested in a smart scale when I started taking Zepbound in January 2025. It has been so helpful in seeing progress beyond weight and BMI.
If you're looking for something similar, I purchased the RENPHO Smart Scale, which has a free app for my phone. Regardless of what brand you choose to buy (though I would appreciate the support through my affiliate link), be sure you're getting measurements like skeletal mass, muscle mass, protein, and water.
Here's an example of the categories Ashley and I focus most on through the GLP-1 Coaching Program. We started in late January and these numbers are through mid-April.
Skeletal Muscle: Went from 18.9% to 25%. A sign of building or restoring muscle while losing fat.
Muscle Mass: Increased from 111.4 lbs to 127.2 lbs, showing significant improvement in strength, metabolism, and overall lean mass
Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR): The number of calories you need to stay alive. Mine increased by 151 calories, a direct result of gaining lean mass and muscle.
Fat-Free Mass: Up from 118.6 lbs to 135.2 lbs. Since my skeletal muscle and muscle mass also increased, this confirms I'm building strength, not just losing fat.
Measuring Muscle Mass by the Numbers
Most people step on a scale and look at one thing: the number. Maybe BMI if they’re feeling ambitious. However, your weight and BMI don't tell you how much of your weight or volume is fat vs. muscle vs. bones.
This nuance becomes especially important if you’re on a GLP-1, where fast weight loss can hide what you’re really losing.
Here’s what anyone on a GLP-1 diet should be looking at:
Lean Body Mass (LBM): This includes everything in your body except fat—muscle, bone, organs, and water. It’s the best rough indicator of whether you’re holding onto muscle. If your weight is going down, but your LBM is staying stable (or only slightly decreasing), that’s a good sign.
Skeletal Muscle Mass (SMM): Some scans (like InBody or DEXA) will break this out. This specifically refers to the muscles attached to your bones—the ones you use for movement, strength, and stability. This is the most useful muscle-specific number. Track it over time. If it’s shrinking, it’s time to increase resistance training and protein.
Muscle Mass: This is the total amount of muscle in your body, and it includes skeletal muscle (the stuff you train and build in workouts), smooth muscle (like in your digestive tract, blood vessels, etc.), and cardiac muscle (your heart).
Body Fat Percentage: If your body fat % is going up while your weight is going down, it could mean you’re losing muscle faster than fat. You want fat % to go down and muscle mass to hold steady or increase. Big drop in LBM? You’re likely losing muscle.
Can You Rebuild Muscle If You’ve Lost It?
Yes, you can rebuild lost muscle—but it’s slower and harder than most people think. Muscle doesn’t just bounce back with a few protein shakes or a couple of walks around the block. It takes weeks or months of consistent effort—especially if you’re still on a GLP-1 and your appetite is working against you.
The good news? Muscle memory is real. If you used to be active or had a strong foundation—even if you’ve gained weight or haven’t trained in years—your muscles “remember” how to grow.
That’s because when you build muscle, your muscle cells increase the number of nuclei inside them. Even after you lose size or strength, those nuclei stick around and make it easier to rebuild when you start training again.
So yes—if you were once fit, you’ve got a head start compared to someone who’s never lifted or trained before. But that memory still needs fuel and activation.
To regain lean mass and protect your metabolism, you need to:
Strength train at least 3-4 times per week
Eat at least 30g of complete protein at each meal
Stay consistent with both food and movement, even when your appetite is low
If you’ve been under-eating or skipping workouts while on a GLP-1, don’t beat yourself up—but do start now. Muscle is easier to protect than to rebuild. And the sooner you begin, the more likely you are to bounce back with strength—not just a lower number on the scale.
How to Start Building Muscle and Eating Right
Several options are available for those on the GLP-1 journey. That includes one-on-one accountability nutrition coaching tailored to you and on-demand workouts that help build strength with a minimal time commitment. Reach out today for a free consultation.
Comments